Untitled Document
Editorial: Schools are not factories
Jakarta (Kompas: (12/11/07) Protest against the national examination for elementary school / Islamic elementary school / elementary school for children with special needs is still going on. The government finally makes a compromise. Schools will be given the authority to determine students’ graduation in the 2008 elementary school national examination. However, in three years, students’ graduation will be determined by a national standard.

Elementary school national examination system in 2008 will be integrated to school final exam called, the integrated national and school final exam (UNTUS). This is a middle way to prepare schools to adapt to the national examination which determines students’ graduation with Mathematics, Natural Sciences and Indonesian Language test. This middle way is expected to quell down protests against elementary school national examination after the government insisted to carry on with the national examination for junior and senior high schools. Protesters argued that the national examination does not reflect the real condition in education. The national examination only portrays a certain moment after students were drilled with the three subject tested in the national examination because schools hope to be able to see as many students as possible to graduate. Education mapping should be based on education process and not merely on the result.

Assessing education merely based on the national examination - albeit education praxis is an objective, process and result – is like treating schools as a factory. In a factory, the most important thing is the product, the process is not very important. In this context, schools - through teachers - form the students to comply by the national standards. Consequently, all the policies are oriented to the result, and not the process. Education praxis is no longer a place where students and teachers meet for teaching and learning process. Education concepts such as its student-oriented nature, liberating and democratic education only remains meaningless catchphrases, set aside by factory-like education praxis.

Such an approach, marked with standards, only make education praxis a tool to achieve a certain result. Meanwhile, the process that leads to the goal, including cheating, commercialization, bribery and drilling students with the subject tested in the national examination is overlooked as long as students manage to pass the exam. In a certain level, such praxis, even though not exactly like a production process in a factory, at least makes school function as a tutorial agency.  The paradigm treating schools like a factory has to be shifted to a new one, which opens to new suggestions and not based on the law of the jungle!

 

Who We Are

Sampoerna Foundation (SF) is a professional philanthropy organization and a service provider for Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) with absolute focus in the field of education. Since 2001, we have given out 30,000 scholarships, adopted 22 schools, offered world-class training for teachers and principals, transformed a graduate business school, and set up a student loan facility. 

We are committed to transparency and accountability in all our activities and expenditures. Outsourcing your CSR activities through SF will allow your company to leverage our best practices and knowledge from more than 200 experts in education and philanthropy management. Sampoerna Foundation is certified ISO-9000-2001 for its quality management systems.